Keeping You Safe, Your Home Smart & Your Life Fun - since 2014

Best Safes: First Alert vs SentrySafe vs Honeywell vs Barska vs Stack-On & More!

How do we keep this site running? This post may contain affiliate links — the cost is the same to you, but we get a referral fee. Compensation does not affect rankings. Thanks!

1st
First Alert logo
2nd
SentrySafe logo
3rd
Honeywell logo

Do you worry about home intruders or in-home workers stealing your most precious possessions? Even if you have a home security system, a home safe can provide an added layer of security against burglars, as well as protecting your valuables from repairmen, housekeepers or other visitors. Whether you just want a simple money safe or more space for important documents, jewelry and other valuables, we have you covered to make a smart choice. Our best home safe reviews give you our top picks for all kinds of safes, including security features, pros and cons, pricing and much more.

What to Consider

Before we launch into our reviews, there are several factors you should consider when shopping around for the best safe for home use.

Where Will You Put Your Safe?

Home burglars typically spend 8-10 minutes in a home, according to the Federal Bureau of Investigation. Where’s the first place they head? A majority head to the master bedroom. Consider these stats when deciding where to put your home safe.

What Will You Be Putting in Your Safe?

If you’ll be storing cash, digital media, important documents (like birth certificates and wills or photo albums), you’ll want a fireproof and water resistant safe. If you plan on storing valuable jewelry, family heirlooms or firearms, you’ll need a safe with added security features.

What Size Safe Should You Get?

Obviously, the size largely depends on what you plan on storing and where you have room for your home safe. If you’re investing a sizable amount of money, it’s a good idea to go a bit larger to give you room to add other items.

Best Home Safe Winners

We’ve based our recommendations on several factors, including security features, quality, durability, value, ease of use and installation, warranty and more. We do include one gun safe in our reviews but check out our full gun safe reviews for more.

First Alert Waterproof Fire Safe Review

First Alert 2092DF#1

View on Amazon

The First Alert 2092DF is our top choice for the best home safe. This model is a triple threat, offering excellent defense against fire, water and theft. Not only is the First Alert 2092DF arguably the best fireproof safe for your home, but it’s also one of few home safes on the market that can float and stay dry even when fully submerged. This safe’s anti-theft features are equally impressive, including four solid locking bolts, pry-resistant concealed hinges, and excellent anchor technology that lets you bolt the safe to the floor without losing its fire and water protection.

Other Features

  • 1.3 cubic feet with removable shelf (spacious enough to fit 3-ring binders)
  • Heavy 93-pound weight deters thieves, or you have the option to bolt the safe to the floor
  • Backlit programmable keypad with emergency override key

Pros

Cons

  • Great value
  • High-quality construction
  • UL certified one-hour resistance to fires up to 1700 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Stays dry when fully submerged
  • Independently verified to protect memory sticks, CD’s, DVD’s, external hard drives and more
  • Ready-seal technology allows you to bolt the safe to the floor without compromising fire/water protection
  • Excellent warranty and after-fire replacement guarantee
  • Initial programming of digital keypad can be difficult
  • Some complaints that the digital keypad stops working after a few months
  • Many owners report high humidity (even mold) in the safe, requiring a dehumidifier
  • Not certified for firearms

Pricing

  • $160.65
  • Batteries and override key included
  • Optional carrying handle (added cost)
  • 5-year limited warranty
  • Lifetime after-fire replacement guarantee
  • Also available in .94 or 2.14 cubic feet models

SentrySafe Combination Fire Safe Review

SentrySafe SFW123DSB#2

View on Amazon

Our number two pick, the SentrySafe SFW123DSB, is another excellent choice for fire, water and theft protection. This SentrySafe model and our top pick share a lot of the same great features. What are main the differences? First, you’re not guaranteed fire and water protection if you bolt this safe to the floor. First Alert’s safe does. And the SentrySafe SFW123DSB has a combination lock rather than a digital lock, so it takes more time to open (not ideal if you want to store a handgun for home protection). But SentrySafe has four thick one-inch bolts for added security. And the humidity factor doesn’t seem to be as bad with SentrySafe as it is with our top pick. If you live in a high humidity climate, SentrySafe could be your better choice.

Other Features

  • 1.23 cubic feet with multi-position shelf
  • Heavy 90-pound weight or you can bolt the safe to the floor (comes with anchoring hardware, but you must drill holes in the safe’s base)
  • Dual combination/key lock provides added security

Pros

Cons

  • Excellent price
  • High-quality construction
  • UL-certified one-hour resistance to fires up to 1700 degrees Fahrenheit
  • ETL-verified water resistance up to 8 inches for 24 hours
  • ETL-verified for 1-hour fire protection of CD’s, DVD’s, memory sticks and USB drives
  • 90-day satisfaction guarantee
  • Made in the USA
  • Several complaints that the lock is difficult to open
  • Safe loses water and fire protection if bolted to the floor
  • Combination lock isn’t backlit
  • Not certified for firearms
  • Warranty only one year

Pricing

  • $179.99
  • Anchor hardware included
  • 1-year limited warranty
  • Lifetime after-fire replacement guarantee
  • Additional shelf and door drawer available for added cost

Honeywell Steel Security Safe Review

Honeywell 5207 Digital-Dial Steel Security Safe#3

View on Amazon

The Honeywell 5207 Digital-Dial Steel Security Safe comes in third place as our best home safe. Unlike our top two picks, this safe isn’t fireproof or water resistant, but its security features and reputation make it a strong contender. This safe consists of thick steel plates, two solid steel locking bolts and hidden pry-resistant hinges for added security. One of the big pluses of this safe is that it has no interior humidity issues (granted, this problem stems from waterproofing technology with other safes). But if you want to store medications or other items that are extremely humidity sensitive in your safe, the Honeywell 5207 is a safe bet.

Other Features

  • 2.7 cubic feet with multi-position shelf
  • Comes with pre-drilled holes and bolting kit
  • Programmable 5 (2-Digit) number code lock (LED displays dial position), companion entry key for added security, and emergency keys

Pros

Cons

  • High-quality steel construction and durable powder coat finish
  • Carpeted interior and flat-bottom doorway help protect contents from damage
  • No consumer complaints about humidity or lock problems
  • Large safe with plenty of room for documents, valuables, etc.
  • Excellent 7-year warranty
  • On the pricey side compared to our top two picks
  • Not fireproof or water resistant
  • Only has two locking bolts (our top two picks have four)
  • Not firearm certified
  • Lighter 60-pound weight isn’t as theft deterrent as our top two picks (but you can bolt it to the floor)

Pricing

  • $209.48
  • Batteries and mounting kit included
  • 7-year warranty

Feature Table

Want a quick side-by-side view of our best home safe winners? Check out our table below that compares the many features you’ll want to consider.

 Winner: First Alert Waterproof Fire Safe2nd Place: SentrySafe Combination Fire Safe3rd Place: Honeywell Steel Security SafeBarska Biometric SafeProtex Electronic Wall SafeStack-On Drawer SafeSteelwater Fireproof SafeZeny Digital Security Safe
Winner: First Alert Waterproof Fire Safe2nd Place: SentrySafe Combination Fire Safe3rd Place: Honeywell Steel Security SafeBarska Biometric SafeProtex Electronic Wall SafeStack-On Drawer SafeSteelwater Fireproof SafeZeny Digital Security Safe
Model Number2092DFSFW123DSB5207AX11224PWS-1814EPDS-1500AMSWEL-360E17
Read ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead Review
View on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on Amazon
Price$160.65$179.99$209.48$169.99$179.55$60.69$369.00
$28.99
Capacity1.31 cubic feet1.23 cubic feet2.73 cubic feet1 cubic feet.44 cubic feet.13 cubic feet.99 cubic feetUnavailable
Exterior Dimensions18"H x 17.5"W x 19.63D17.8"H x 16.3W x 19.3"D21.65"H x 14.96"W x 17.99"D16.5"H x 14.5"W x 4"D18.25"H x 14"W x 4"D4.5"H x 12"W x 8.75"D13.75"H x 19.25"W x 16.75"D6.7"H x 9"W x 6.7"D
Weight93 lbs90 lbs60 lbs25 lbs28 lbs13.5 lbs115 lbs8 lbs
Fire ProtectionCheckmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Water ResistantCheckmark
Checkmark
Steel Plates
Checkmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Anchor ReadyCheckmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Lock TypeDigital KeypadDual Combination/KeyDigital KeypadFingerprint ScannerDigital KeypadDigital KeypadDigital KeypadDigital Keypad
Drilling ProtectionCheckmark
California Certified Gun SafeCheckmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
LED LightCheckmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Number of Shelves Included1120201
Warranty5 Years1 Year7 Years1 Year1 Year3 Years1 YearUnavailable
Lifetime GuaranteeCheckmark
Checkmark
Checkmark
Read ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead Review
View on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on Amazon
Model Number2092DFSFW123DSB5207AX11224PWS-1814EPDS-1500AMSWEL-360E17

Other Best Home Safe Reviews

The following safes didn’t make out top three winners, but there’s stiff competition in the home safe market. Each of these safes deserves serious consideration, depending on your security needs.

Barska Biometric Safe | Protex Electronic Wall Safe | Stack-On Drawer Safe | Steelwater Fireproof Safe | Zeny Digital Security Safe

Barska Biometric Safe Review

Barska Biometric SafeView on Amazon

The Barska Biometric Safe is an affordable and sturdy home safe. This safe is firearm certified and has fingerprint technology, making it quick and easy to open. It’s compact enough to fit under a bed but still has enough room for small electronics, a firearm, jewelry, important documents, medications and more. And it comes with bolting hardware so you can mount it to the floor or shelving. The Barska Biometric Safe is one of the best small home safes on the market.

Pros

Cons

  • Great value
  • High-quality construction with steel walls and motorized deadbolt lock
  • Department of Justice (DOJ) certified firearm safe
  • No humidity issues
  • Inner floor mat protects contents from getting scratched
  • Stores up to 30 fingerprints
  • Not fireproof or water resistant
  • Some customer reports that safe doesn’t always easily recognize fingerprints
  • Warranty only one year

Pricing

  • $169.99
  • Inner floor mat, emergency back-up keys, mounting hardware and batteries included
  • 1-year warranty

Protex Electronic Wall Safe Review

Protex Electronic Wall Safe (PWS-1814E)View on Amazon

Are you looking for a hidden wall safe? Protex Electronic Wall Safe (PWS-1814E) is one of the best wall safes you’ll find. This safe consists of heavy gauge steel and has dual live motorized 3/4″ chrome bolts and a 5/8″ thick formed steel door. The digital lock is easy to open and has a 15-minute security timeout after three attempts to unlock the safe. As with most wall safes, the Protex requires either a hired contractor or strong handyman skills for installation. It fits between 16″ o/c wall studs and will accommodate any height.

Pros

Cons

  • Affordable pricing
  • High-quality heavy gauge steel construction with 2 locking bolts
  • No humidity issues
  • LED lighting inside safe
  • Comes with a flange, so you don’t need to re-plaster walls
  • Velvet-lined interior protects your valuables
  • Not fireproof or water resistant
  • Not certified for firearms
  • Need some DIY skills for installation
  • No LED lights on keypad
  • Warranty is only one year

Pricing

  • $179.55
  • Batteries, mounting hardware, 2 override keys, 2 removable shelves and flange included
  • 1-year warranty

Stack-On Drawer Safe Review

Stack-On PDS-1500 Drawer SafeView on Amazon

The Stack-On PDS-1500 Drawer Safe is a popular choice for people wanting a portable or small home safe. This compact, lightweight safe fits in a nightstand, desk drawer or under a car seat; yet, it’s also mountable to floors, walls or shelves in your home. And it features great security measures, including solid steel walls, a plate steel door, hidden pry-resistant hinges, and steel live-action locking bolts. The electronic lock is very reliable and has a timeout feature after three failed attempts.

Pros

Cons

  • Very affordable pricing
  • High-quality solid steel construction with steel locking bolts
  • Easy to program and use
  • California certified gun safe
  • No humidity issues
  • Good 3-year warranty
  • Made in the USA
  • Not fireproof or water resistant
  • Should bolt down if used as a home safe (due to lighter weight)
  • Keypad isn’t backlit
  • Several consumer complaints about extremely short battery life

Pricing

  • $60.69
  • Batteries, mounting hardware and backup key included

Steelwater Fireproof Safe Review

Steelwater AMSWEL-360View on Amazon

The Steelwater AMSWEL-360 is a great choice if you’re looking for a heavy duty, drill-proof and fireproof safe. With two layers of heavy gauge steel surrounding your valuables, this safe is an excellent deterrent to even experienced burglars. Steelwater also makes fantastic fire-rated safes, and this model is no exception. Another plus is the reliable electronic keypad that includes four reprogrammable (4-16) digit combinations that won’t get lost if the batteries die. Just replace the batteries in the external battery compartment, and you’re good to go. Many safes don’t have this level of combination memory. If you want major water resistance, this isn’t the safe for you. But without the waterproof sealing, you won’t face the associated humidity problems.

Pros

Cons

  • Excellent security with 2 steel layers on walls and door, 4 solid steel locking bolts (2 on door and 2 on hinges)
  • Two-hour fire rated at 1850°F
  • No humidity issues
  • Fantastic warranty and lifetime guarantee
  • On the expensive side
  • Not waterproof (minimally water resistant)
  • Keypad isn’t backlit
  • Small safe at .99 cubic feet

Pricing

  • $369.00
  • Batteries included
  • 1-year full warranty (90 days for digital components)
  • Lifetime guarantee for burglary and fire (must be bolted down to qualify)

Zeny Digital Security Safe Review

Zeny Digital Security SafeView on Amazon

You can’t put a price on safety, but sometimes your budget doesn’t agree. Fortunately, there’s the Zeny Digital Security Safe, a budget-friendly, Amazon-bestselling safe that’s sturdy and reliable.  Constructed with 2mm thick solid steel and a 4mm thick front door for added security, this safe also has a heavy-duty chrome steel dual 3/4″ pin bolt and tamper-proof hinges. This safe also has a time-out period after three incorrect combination attempts. It’s a small safe — you can fit a small firearm or money and jewelry but not much else. Still, Zeny is one of the best cheap safes on the market.

Pros

Cons

  • Budget-friendly
  • Good security features, including solid steel construction
  • Light weight makes it a good portable safe
  • Excellent reviews by Amazon customers
  • Not fireproof or water resistant
  • Should bolt down if used as a home safe (due to lighter weight)
  • Keypad isn’t backlit
  • Batteries not included

Pricing

  • $28.99
  • Mounting kit and 2 override keys included
  • No warranty information available

How Are Fireproof Safes Tested?

Check out the video below to see how Underwriters Laboratories (UL) tests home safes like our top two winners. UL is an independent safety consulting and certification company that’s widely considered the gold-standard.

Unlock Your Home Security Potential

We hope our home safes reviews have given you the information you need to crack into this enormous market. Getting a home safe is a wise investment. Just consider the statistics. More than 2 million burglaries are reported in the U.S. every year, with 66% of those being home invasions. Whether you want to protect your valuables against fire, flood or burglary, our picks are excellent choices.

What positive or negative experiences have you had with a home safe?

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Sally is a passionate writer but her interests do not stop there. She spends a lot of time daydreaming about the beach, however, she spends most of her time taking advantage of all the activities her town has to offer in the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains.

Leave a Reply

1 Comment on "Best Safes: First Alert vs SentrySafe vs Honeywell vs Barska vs Stack-On & More!"

avatar
Anonymous
Anonymous
Sadly nothing is safe anymore…my mom’s jewelry was stolen recently and don’t want this to happen to me, so going to get one of these for sure!
wpDiscuz

Send this to a friend