Best Mattress In A Box: Saatva vs Leesa vs Casper vs Purple vs Nectar vs Tuft & Needle vs Lull vs Helix & More

To sustain this free service, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. This doesn’t affect rankings. Our review process.

Best For Couples
Casper logo
Best For Side Sleepers
 Leesa logo
Best For Back Sleepers
Purple logo
Best Value
Tuft & Needle logo

Can you really get the ideal mattress online? You bet! You also get some outstanding benefits, namely much more affordable pricing and ridiculously long trial periods (with free returns and full refunds). Ditch the showroom, and consider our mattress in a box review recommendations instead.

Article Overview

Best For Couples: Casper Review

picture of a bed and Casper box Visit Website | View on Amazon

Casper, one of the first bed in a box mattress companies and the industry leader in sales, offers two memory foam mattresses and one mixed foam and latex mattress (The Essential). All three models provide mid-level firmness, with extra layers as you price up.

The Casper, it’s most popular model, gives you good support around your hips, shoulders and other pressure areas. It’s also great for couples because it absorbs movement and bounce very well.

The Wave, its high-end mattress, offers even more targeted ergonomic support, but it’s more expensive than comparable mattresses. If you’re looking for a cooling mattress, Casper’s models are about average in keeping you cool vs being too hot.

Pros

Cons

  • Every layer is CertiPUR-US certified and free of ozone-depleting chemicals and emissions
  • They donate returned mattresses to charity
  • Excellent customer support via live chat and phone
  • Weak edge support
  • Has a strong chemical odor for about a week
  • Some customer complaints that the mattress sags over time

Price

  • The Essential (8.5”, 3 layers): ranges from $350 – $725
  • The Casper (10”, 4 layers):
  • The Wave (11.5”, 5 layers): ranges from $1,095 – $2,395
  • Free shipping
  • 100-day return with free pickup
  • 10-year warranty

Best For Side & Stomach Sleepers: Leesa Review

Picture of a bedroom Visit Website | View on Amazon

Leesa is a top-rated mattress in a box company and is probably most comparable to the Casper, although it’s a bit more firm than Casper (our pick for couples). Leesa offers two models: the classic Leesa is 10-inch memory foam, and the Sapira is an 11-inch hybrid foam and spring construction.

These mattresses are super comfy, with a soft yet supportive feel. They’re great for all kinds of sleepers and absorb bounce well.

Pros

Cons

  • CertiPUR-US certified
  • They donate 1 mattress for every 10 they sell to homeless shelters
  • Made in the U.S.
  • Excellent customer support via live chat and phone
  • Doesn’t offer a budget mattress
  • Might be too hot for some
  • Some complaints that it sags in the middle over time

Price

  • Classic Leesa (10″):
  • Sapria (11″): ranges from $995 – $1,795
  • Free shipping
  • 100-day return with free pickup
  • 10-year warranty

Best For Back Sleepers: Purple Review

Picture of a bedroom Visit Website | View on Amazon

Purple uses their innovative creation of a Hyper-Elastic Polymer top layer that’s in a patented grid formation on top of a dual-layer foam base. The polymer is firm around your pressure points, making it an excellent option for back sleepers or people that are heavier and need more support.

This mattress helps align your spine in any sleep position and equalizes pressure weight throughout your body. The grid design also makes it more breathable for a cooler sleeping experience. Purple has also introduced the “New Purple” premium mattress that replaces the foam base layer with responsive support coils and the option of a thicker top layer.

Pros

Cons

  • Made from hyper-elastic polymer that’s FDA and CertiPUR-US certified
  • Free in-home delivery and setup
  • Made in the U.S.
  • Excellent customer support via live chat and phone
  • Many side sleepers say it’s too firm
  • Not available in standard Twin size (only Twin XL)
  • No information on website about what they do with returned mattresses

Price

  • The Original Purple Mattress (9.5″, 3 layers):
  • The New Purple Mattress (9.5″-13.5″, 3-5 layers): ranges from $1,299 – $3,499
  • Free shipping
  • 100-day return with free pickup
  • 10-year warranty

Best Value: Tuft & Needle Review

Picure of a bedroom Visit Website | View on Amazon

Tuft & Needle’s mattresses are unbeatable for their combination of high-quality construction, comfort and attractive price point. This mattress is made of the company’s unique T&N Adaptive foam that’s soft yet provides great pressure relief 
where you need it.

The foam also includes breathable heat wicking graphite and cooling gel to keep you comfortable. Out of more than 6,500 customer reviews on Amazon, 78% give Tuft & Needle’s mattress 5 stars, and the company claims they have an impressively low 5% return rate.

Tuft & Needle’s upgraded Mint mattress is also a good value. This higher-end model has an added layer, enhanced edge support, a thicker charcoal knitted cover, and more graphite and gel beads for added support and cooling.

Pros

Cons

  • Excellent value
  • CertiPUR-US, Oeko-Tex 100 and Greenguard certified for eco-friendly and allergen-free materials
  • They donate returned mattresses to charity
  • Made in the U.S.
  • Excellent customer support via live chat and phone
  • A few customer complaints that the T&N model is  too hot

Price

  • T&N Mattress (10″, 2 layers):
  • Mint Mattress (12″, 3 layers): ranges from $650 to $1,050
  • Free shipping
  • 100-day return with free pickup
  • 10-year warranty

Other Best Bed In A Box Reviews

The following are some other top-rated and popular choices for online mattress companies.

Lull | Nectar | Saatva

Lull Review

Picure of a bedroom Visit Website | View on Amazon

Lull offers a top-rated memory foam mattress in a box that’s slightly on the firm side and does a good job of giving you a cooling sleep. It’s designed to support all your pressure points and has good motion isolation. If you’re not a fan of the memory foam feel, this probably isn’t the mattress for you. Otherwise, it’s a best buy in our book.

Pros

Cons

  • Affordably priced
  • CertiPUR-US certified for no harmful chemicals or off-gassing
  • Eco-friendly company that uses locally sourced materials
  • Made in the U.S.
  • Excellent customer support ratings
  • Not for people who dislike the feel of memory foam
  • Several complaints that it’s way too firm
  • No information on website about what they do with returned mattresses

Price

  • The Lull Mattress (10″, 3 layers):
  • Free shipping
  • 100-day return with free pickup
  • 10-year warranty

Nectar Sleep Review

Picture of a bed with a brick wall behind it Visit Website | View on Amazon

Nectar Sleep provides several industry-leading perks you may not want to pass up — an astounding 365-day return policy, a forever warranty and a no bed bug guarantee. Its gel memory foam mattress is a bit more firm than the Casper and Leesa mattresses, but many side sleepers give it high ratings.

Pros

Cons

  • Lower price point than many competitors
  • CertiPUR-US certified for no harmful chemicals or gasses
  • 365-day return policy
  • Forever warranty
  • No replacement covers available for purchase
  • Some complaints about poor customer support
  • No information on website about what they do with returned mattresses

Price

  • The Nectar (11″, 3 layers):
  • Free shipping
  • 365-day return with free pickup
  • Forever warranty

Saatva Review

Picute of a Saavta Mattress with comforter and pillows Visit Website

Saatva is another best place to buy a mattress online. The Saatva mattress comes in three firmness levels, Soft Plush, Luxury Firm and Firm. Unlike our other reviewed companies, Saatva has an upper coil layer. All coils are foam-encased for superior comfort and support.

The Saatva also incorporates a memory foam layer and steel coil base for an all-around well-constructed spring coil mattress that’s a lot more affordable than traditional spring coils you’ll find in stores. You can also choose the thickness, 14.5″ or 11.5″ — both sleep the same; it’s a matter of how tall you want your mattress.

Pros

Cons

  • CertiPUR-US certified for no harmful chemicals or gasses
  • Free in-home delivery and setup
  • Organic cotton cover with botanical antimicrobial fabric treatment that inhibits bacteria
  • Inner springs made from recycled steel
  • 120-day return policy
  • Made in the U.S.
  • Customers report extremely helpful sales and support reps
  • On the pricey side
  • $99 return transportation fee
  • After 2 years, Saatva’s warranty only covers repairs and re-covering and you must pay $99 shipping costs each way

Price

  • The Saatva (14.5″ or 11.5″, 3 layers): ranges from $599 – $1,399
  • Free shipping
  • 120-day return policy
  • 2-year replacement warranty
  • 13-year repair warranty

How Do I Choose The Best Mattress?

Experts agree that the best way to find the ideal mattress is to test it out. That’s one of the main benefits of buying a mattress from one of our online mattress company reviews — they give you plenty of time to see if it’s “the one.” Check out the following video to see what else to consider when choosing the best mattress for you.

What About Room Temperature?

Do you want to make sure your bedroom is the ideal temperature when it’s time for bed? The recommended temperature for sleeping is 69°F, but everyone’s different. Check out our reviews of the best smart WiFi thermostats that you can set whenever and from wherever you are. You could even set a sleep schedule to cool your bedroom at nightfall.

Which online mattresses have you tried? Did you like it?

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Sally is a passionate writer but her interests do not stop there. She spends a lot of time daydreaming about the beach, however, she spends most of her time taking advantage of all the activities her town has to offer in the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains.

Leave a Reply

avatar