Best Smart Scale: Qardiobase vs Withings vs Fitbit Aria vs Yunmai vs Weight Gurus vs Garmin
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Here’s how it works.
| 1st |
 |
| 2nd |
 |
| 3rd |
 |
Smart scales go way beyond just recording your weight. Many take multiple readings of everything from your body mass index to bone mass — and these best wifi scales sync with apps on your smartphone to help you keep a more complete handle on your overall fitness.
Get the skinny on the best scales on the market as we weigh the pros and cons of each.
Best Smart Scales Winners
We took six factors into account in our smart scale comparison reviews:
- Range of measurements taken
- Connection stability to Bluetooth and/or WiFi
- App performance
- Integration with third-party fitness apps
- Pricing
- Warranty
You’ll see these features highlighted in our pros and cons in each review write up.
Winner: Weight Gurus Bluetooth Smart Connected Body Fat Scale Review
The Weight Gurus Bluetooth scale is our top choice as the best smart weight scale for its impressive value.
This scale measures weight, body mass index (BMI), body fat, muscle mass, water weight and bone mass and syncs seamlessly with many popular fitness apps via your iPhone or Android.
With four precise weighing sensors, the Weight Gurus ensures an accuracy of +/- 0.2 pounds. Plus you get all of this for roughly $40 less than the big-name smart scales.
We also love that a portion of your purchase goes to their partner, Love146, a charitable organization committed to ending child trafficking.
Pros |
Cons |
|
|
Pricing & Tech Specs
- Check Amazon for availability
- Includes 4 AAA batteries
- Up to 8 users
- Dimensions: .9″H x 12.6″L x 12.6″W
- Weight limit: 400 lbs
- Black or white
- 5-year warranty
Yunmai Premium Smart Scale Review
The Yunmai Premium Smart Bluetooth Scale comes in a very close second in our smart scale reviews.
Like our number one pick, this scale falls into the same price range and syncs with popular fitness apps via a Bluetooth connection.
Not only is the Yunmai an accurate weight and body fat scale, but it also measures BMI, muscle, hydration, bone mass and more.
What kept this scale out of our top spot? The user complaints about the Yunmai app crashing frequently and its 1-year warranty compared to 5 years for the Weight Gurus.
Pros |
Cons |
|
|
Pricing
- $69.95
- Includes 4 AAA batteries
- Up to 16 users
- Dimensions: 1.2″H x 12.9″L x 12.9″W
- Weight limit: 396 lbs
- Black or white
- 1-year warranty
1byone Bluetooth Body Fat Scale Review
The 1byone Bluetooth Body Fat Scale rounds out our top three best smart scale picks. This Bluetooth scale measures weight, body fat, water, muscle mass, BMI, BMR, and bone mass visceral fat.
While you have to have the app open to view all the measurements (the scale only displays weight), users report a quick setup process and not many problems with connectivity.
This scale is an exceptional value if you can live without the syncing capability to most third-party fitness apps.
Pros |
Cons |
|
|
Pricing
- Check Amazon for availability
- Includes 4 AAA batteries
- Up to 10 users
- Dimensions: 1.1″H x 11.8″L x 11.8″W
- Weight limit: 400 lbs
- Black or white
- 1-year warranty
What About Fitbit, Garmin, Nokia, And OardioBase?
Below, you’ll find our reviews of some other popular smart scales that didn’t make it into our top 3 rankings this year. Be sure to read them if you’ve been considering a specific brand. Don’t see your favorite brand? Ask us to review it in the comments.
Fitbit Aria | Garmin Index | Nokia Body+ | QardioBase
Fitbit Aria WiFi Smart Scale Review
If you are a Fitbit fan, the Fitbit Aria WiFi Scale is a handy companion to help you with your weight loss and fitness goals.
This scale tracks weight, BMI, lean mass, and body fat percentages and automatically loads your stats into your Fitbit app. It also syncs with many other fitness apps.
The main problems with the Aria, according to many user reviews on Amazon, are its faulty WiFi connection (constantly going out) and a short scale life (12-18 months on average) on top of a warranty for only one year.
Pros |
Cons |
|
|
Pricing
- Check Amazon for availability
- Includes 4 AA batteries
- Up to 8 users
- Dimensions: 1.3″H x 12.3″L x 12.3″W
- Weight limit: 350 lbs
- Black or white
- 1-year warranty
Garmin Index Smart Scale Review
The Garmin Index Smart WiFi Scale tracks more body measurements than many other smart scales, including weight, BMI, body fat and water percentages, skeletal muscle mass, and bone mass.
This smart bathroom scale is wider than most and is much easier to set up than the Fitbit Aria, and it syncs your data to their Garmin Connect online fitness community via Bluetooth and WiFi.
But the Garmin Index has a bad reputation for connectivity issues, and it’s expensive. We think you can find better deals elsewhere.
Pros |
Cons |
|
|
Pricing
- Check Amazon for availability
- Includes 4 AA batteries
- Up to 16 users
- Dimensions: 1.2″H x 12.2″L x 13.8″W
- Weight limit: 400 lbs
- Black or white
- 1-year warranty
Nokia Body+ WiFi Scale Review
The Nokia Body+ Body Composition WiFi Scale is the former best-selling Withings Smart Body Analyzer, and this scale used to be the one to beat.
But since Nokia bought out Withings, things have gone downhill, according to many users and reviewers. While the scale still measures weight, fat mass, muscle mass, water and bone mass, the problem lies in the Nokia app that’s supposed to sync with the scale via WiFi or Bluetooth.
A handful of users report no issues, but a vast majority can’t get the app to work properly (or at all). If Nokia can get its app in shape, this scale could again be a top contender.
Pros |
Cons |
|
|
Pricing
- $99.95
- Includes 4 AAA batteries
- Up to 8 users
- Dimensions: .9″H x 12.8″L x 12.8″W
- Weight limit: 396 lbs
- Black or white
- 1-year warranty
QardioBase Smart Digital Scale Review
The QardioBase Smart Digital is another smart bathroom scale that measures body mass index and full body composition, including body fat percentage, muscle, water and bone mass. And it syncs with the QardioBase app on multiple devices via Bluetooth and WiFi.
However, this scale suffers similar problems that other “top” scales do, namely connection issues and the device dying too soon. In fact, this scale gets such poor reviews on Amazon; we can’t recommend it at this time. QardioBase 2 was recently released, and we’ll keep our eye out to see if it’s an improved version.
Pros |
Cons |
|
|
Pricing
- Includes 8 AAA batteries
- Multiple users
- Dimensions: .8″H x 12.6″L x 12.6″W
- Weight limit: 396 lbs
- Black or white
- 3-year limited warranty
What’s The Latest Fitness Gadget Technology?
Check out the video below for some of the latest fitness gadget technology.
Who Makes The Best Activity Tracker?
Smart scales are only part of the growing high-tech fitness industry. If you don’t already have a Fitbit or other wearable activity tracker, be sure to check out our activity tracker comparison, which compares the top fitness wearables on the market.
