IdentityForce vs Identity Guard: Which Has Better ID Theft Protection?

To sustain this free service, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. This doesn’t affect rankings. Our review process.

IdentityForce vs Identity Guard logosWe’ve put two of the biggest names in identity theft protection in a head-to-head battle: IdentityForce vs Identity Guard. Which one comes out on top?

Visit IdentityForce’s Website | Visit Identity Guard’s Website

 IdentityForceIdentity Guard
Monitoring CoverageCheckmark
Recovery ServicesCheckmark
Customer Service & ReputationCheckmarkCheckmark
Mobile AccessCheckmark
Family/Child ProtectionCheckmark
Overall WinnerCheckmark

Protecting consumers since 2005, IdentityForce has an excellent reputation. Their accolades include Identity Protection Leader by Javelin, People’s Choice Stevie Awards for Favorite New Product, a Gold Stevie Award for having the best product in the industry, and more.

Identity Guard’s parent company, Intersections Inc., has been a leading ID theft service for over 20 years. Kiplinger magazine named Identity Guard its #1 best ID theft protection service in 2015, and they were also recognized in the Online Trust Honor Roll in 2017.

Monitoring Coverage

IdentityForce leads the industry in monitoring coverage. They monitor nearly everything you can imagine and send you alerts to your smartphone and credit bureaus based on the type of suspicious activity they’ve detected.

Identity Guard covers a lot compared to many other services, but they lack driver’s license, email and sex offender monitoring, all of which you get with IdentityForce. They also don’t send fraud alerts to your credit bureaus.identity force logo

Winner: IdentityForce

Recovery Services

IdentityForce blows Identity Guard out of the water in the recovery services they offer. While Identity Guard leaves a lot of ID recovery to your own devices, IdentityForce provides full recovery services, including 24/7 access to their fraud specialists.

IdentityForce’s theft experts take care of most of the recovery process for you, including contacting your financial institutions, handling paperwork, helping to secure attorney assistance if needed, and more. Each service, however, does provide a service guarantee (up to $1 million) to cover expenses you could incur if your identity gets stolen.identity force logo

Winner: IdentityForce 

Customer Service & Reputation

IdentityForce and Identity Guard both stand out for exceptional customer support and reputations. These two companies provide U.S.-based, 24/7 access to certified ID theft specialists and general customer service. Their websites also have a lot of useful resources about identity theft and the recovery process.

We also looked at online customer reviews for both companies. Identity Guard customer complaints focused mainly on hit or miss customer service reps. The IdentityForce complaints we found primarily involved problems accessing accounts online, but this didn’t appear to be a widespread problem.IdentityForce and Identity Guard logos

Winner: IdentityForce and Identity Guard (Tie)

Mobile Access

Both IdentityForce and Identity Guard have apps for iOS and Android smartphones, where you get instant fraud alerts. Both companies’ mobile apps, however, are limited compared to what you can do on their websites.

App users overwhelmingly prefer IdentityForce to Identity Guard. We found many complaints about Identity Guard’s apps for both iOS and Android that they’re buggy, unreliable and difficult to use.identity force logo

Winner: IdentityForce

Family/Child Coverage

Identity Guard blows IdentityForce out of the water in this category. Identity Guard offers three different family plans that are among the most affordable you’ll find. IdentityForce only provides a child add-on plan but nothing for multiple adults in a household. Identity Force Child Watch, however, is reasonably priced at an additional $2.75 per month per child.Identity Guard logo

Winner: Identity Guard


Both services offer competitive pricing for the industry. As an individual, you’ll save more if you go with Identity Guard’s lowest plan compared to IdentityForce’s least expensive plan. If you want all the features each company has to offer, IdentityForce comes out on top. If you also want to cover a spouse or your family, however, Identity Guard’s family plans can save you a chunk of change, which is why it wins this category.Identity Guard logo

Winner: Identity Guard

IdentityForce vs Identity Guard Plans

 IdentityForceIdentityForceIdentity GuardIdentity GuardIdentity Guard
UltraSecureUltraSecure+CreditEssentialsTotal ProtectionPlatinum
Visit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit Website
Price Per Month$12.95/month$19.95/month$8.99/month$16.99/month$22.99/month
Free Trial14 days30 days30 days
U.S.-Based Agents 24/7CheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Full Identity Recovery SupportCheckmarkCheckmark
SSN MonitoringCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Driver's License MonitoringCheckmarkCheckmark
Credit Card Monitoring & Activity AlertsCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Bank Account Monitoring & Activity AlertsCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Address Change VerificationCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Black Market Website SurveillanceCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Lost Wallet AssistanceCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Alerts for New Account AttemptsCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Payday Loan MonitoringCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Medical ID MonitoringCheckmarkCheckmark
Court Records ScanningCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Sex Offender Registry ReportsCheckmarkCheckmark
Online Annual Credit Reports and Scores3 Credit Bureaus3 Credit Bureaus3 Credit Bureaus
Credit Score TrackingThree Bureaus, DailyThree Bureaus, QuarterlyThree Bureaus, Monthly
Service GuaranteeUp to $1 millionUp to $1 millionUp to $1 millionUp to $1 millionUp to $1 million
Stolen Funds ReplacementIncluded in Service GuaranteeIncluded in Service Guarantee
Personal Expense ReimbursementIncluded in Service GuaranteeIncluded in Service Guarantee
Coverage for Lawyers & ExpertsIncluded in Service GuaranteeIncluded in Service Guarantee

IdentityForce Discount

IdentityForce offers two plans, UltraSecure and UltraSecure+Credit, with the option of adding on their supplemental Child Watch plan to either subscription. The standard cost of the UltraSecure IdentityForce plan is $17.95/month or $179.50/year, but our readers are eligible for the discounted rate of $12.95/month or $129.50/year. The standard cost of UltraSecure+Credit is $23.95/month and $239.50/year, but our readers can get this service for $19.95/month or $199.50/year. Click here to take advantage of these offers! You can also visit our dedicated IdentityForce coupon page to discuss current offers.

Identity Guard Multi-Person Plans

The following plans share the same features as the Identity Guard Total Protection Plan.

  • $26.99 per month for 2 adults
  • $24.99 per month for 1 adult and children
  • $27.99 per month for 2 adults and children

Identity Guard Coupon

Enrolling with Identity Guard through our link saves you 10% off the homepage prices! You can also visit our dedicated Identity Guard coupon page to discuss current offers.

Overall Winner In IdentityForce vs Identity Guard

And our winner is… IdentityForce! No other ID theft protection service gives you the level of monitoring and recovery services at an affordable monthly cost than IdentityForce. To top it off, you also get excellent customer support and a handy mobile app that sends you reliable fraud alerts.

Although our winner is IdentityForce, Identity Guard is worth serious consideration — especially if you want whole family coverage. Both of these services are excellent options.identity force logo

Winner: IdentityForce

Before you make a final decision, be sure to check out our best identity theft protection services review to see how each company performed versus the other big players.

Why are you considering identity theft protection?

*Identity Theft insurance underwritten by insurance company subsidiaries or affiliates of American International Group, Inc. The description herein is a summary and intended for informational purposes only and does not include all terms, conditions and exclusions of the policies described. Please refer to the actual policies for terms, conditions, and exclusions of coverage. Coverage may not be available in all jurisdictions.

Identity Guard™ Disclosures
*The scores you receive with Identity Guard™ are provided for educational purposes to help you understand your credit. Lenders use many different scoring systems, and the scores you receive with Identity Guard™ are not the same scores used by lenders to evaluate your credit.
Credit scores are provided by CreditXpert® based on data from the credit reporting bureaus. If you do not cancel your membership, your card will be charged a monthly fee based on the membership plan you choose. You man cancel your membership anytime simply by contacting Identity Guard™.
**Identity Theft Insurance underwritten by insurance company subsidiaries or affiliates of American International Group, Inc. The description herein is a summary and intended for informational purposes only and does not include all terms, conditions, and exclusions of the policies described. Please refer to the actual policies for terms, conditions, and exclusions of coverage. Coverage may not be available in all jurisdictions.

Sally is a passionate writer but her interests do not stop there. She spends a lot of time daydreaming about the beach, however, she spends most of her time taking advantage of all the activities her town has to offer in the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains.

Leave a Reply