Best Baby Swing: 4moms mamaRoo vs Graco Swing vs Fisher-Price Swing & More

To keep the lights on, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. Our review process.

Top Rated Fisher price logo
View on Amazon | Read Review
Bouncer 4moms logo
Newborn Graco
Rocker Graco
Portable Ingenuity

Trying to soothe a fussy baby is hard work. Having the right swing can make all the difference. Swings provide babies with a comforting motion that mimics being in the womb. They also give caregivers a break from holding their baby, so they can catch up on chores or just take a much-needed break.

Best Baby Swings

All of the swings we recommend have a high rating for the safety of your child. We considered several criteria including features, cost, customer reviews and more. There are a lot of swings on the market, so we break them down into 5 categories to help you choose what’s best for you.

Best Top-Rated Baby Swing: Fisher-Price Sweet Snuggapuppy Dreams Cradle N’ Swing

Fisher-Price Sweet Snuggapuppy Dreams Cradle N' Swing

View on Amazon

Of all the top-rated baby swings we considered, the Fisher-Price Sweet Snuggapuppy Dreams Cradle N’ Swings is our top pick. This swing is soft and comfortable for your little bundle of joy. It will keep your baby engaged and entertained with an overhead mirrored dome and mobile. Several sound settings can help soothe your baby, and the swing can rotate front to back or side to side.

The battery power and plug-in features allow you to place the swing anywhere you’d like it, even outdoors. The 5-point harness keeps your baby secure, and the many options for sensory stimulation helps encourage your baby’s development.

The one thing this swing lacks is a vibration setting. You also need to consider its 25-pound weight limit and that it can be a bit noisy.

Personal Experience

I bought this swing for my first child. It was a lifesaver. He loved to be in the swing, and it provided me with the opportunity to put him down and get things done. I really like the mirrored dome feature. It seemed to keep my son’s attention more than just a mobile. Overall, it has everything I was looking for, and it proved to be a fantastic choice. – Julie F., Safe Smart Living Contributor

Pros

Cons

  • 16 sound options
  • 5-point harness
  • Seat can swing side to side or front to  back
  • 6 swing speeds
  • Reclining seat
  • Infant support insert included
  • Batteries or plug-in
  • Machine washable fabric
  • 25 lb weight limit
  • No vibration setting
  • Loud

Price

  • Fisher-Price Sweet Snugapuppy Dreams Cradle 'n Swing
    Fisher-Price Sweet Snugapuppy Dreams Cradle 'n Swing
    $169.99

Best Newborn Baby Swing: Graco Simple Sway LX Baby Swing

Graco Simple Sway LX Baby Swing

View on Amazon

The Graco Simple Sway LX Baby Swing is our pick for the best newborn baby swing. What makes it special for newborns is the recommended starting weight of 5.5 pounds, removable infant head support, secure 5-point harness, reclined position and 2-speed vibration. And it has a great upper weight limit of 30 pounds.

This swing also has an overhead mobile, 15 sound options, 6 swing speeds and front-to-back or side-to-side swinging options. Some things we don’t love about this swing? It stays in the recline position and it can be loud when in motion.

Pros

Cons

  • 15 sound options
  • 5-point harness
  • Seat rotates to swing side to side or front to back
  • 6 swing speeds
  • 30 lb weight limit
  • Infant support insert included
  • 2-speed vibration setting
  • Batteries or plug-in
  • Machine washable fabric
  • Seat stays in recline position
  • Loud

Price

Best Rocker Baby Swing: Graco DuetSoothe Baby Swing and Rocker

Graco DuetSoothe Baby Swing and Rocker

View on Amazon

Some swings are also a rocker. The Graco DuetSoothe Baby Swing and Rocker is our top pick in this category. What’s cool about this product is that you can take the seat off of the swinging base and use it as a rocker. This feature makes it easy to take your baby with you as you move around the house during your day.

There are lots of excellent features in this swing. It can help keep your baby entertained with the 15 sound options and the overhead mobile. The swing can help soothe a fussy baby with 6 swing speeds and 2 vibration settings, and the fact that it’s battery powered gives you more choices on placement.

Personal Experience

We purchased this swing for our son when he was a newborn, and it was one of the best baby products we bought. When he was fussy (which was often), he loved for us to bounce with him on an exercise ball. If we were too exhausted to bounce, we’d try the swing and it helped calm him down. The vibration and swinging can get loud, but I think he found the noise soothing. We’d also play a “shushing” video on YouTube; he loved being shushed, and it helped calm him as well.

– Kimberly A., Safe Smart Living Contributor

Pros

Cons

  • 15 sound options
  • 5-point harness
  • Seat rotates to swing side to side and front to back
  • 6 swing speeds
  • Reclining seat
  • 30 lb weight limit
  • Infant support insert included
  • 2 vibration settings
  • Battery-powered
  • Machine washable fabric
  • Loud

Price

Best Portable Baby Swing: Ingenuity Swing ‘n Go Portable Swing

Ingenuity Swing 'n Go Portable Swing

View on Amazon

Sometimes you need a swing that you can take on the go. The Ingenuity Swing ‘n Go Portable Swing is our #1 choice in this category. This swing is smaller and lighter weight than the other swings we review, and its portability is the best feature.

It’s battery powered, has a 5-point harness for safety and can help entertain your baby with an overhead mobile, 5 swing speeds and 12 sound options. Two unique features are the whisper-quiet operation for gentle, quiet motion and true speed technology to help keep the speed consistent.

You do need to consider the 20-pound weight limit since it won’t accommodate your baby as long as some other options. It also doesn’t have a reclining seat, does not vibrate and only swings front to back.

Pros

Cons

  • 12 sound options
  • 5-point harness
  • 5 swing speeds
  • Very quiet
  • Battery-powered
  • Machine washable fabric
  • Only swings front to back
  • 20 lb weight limit
  • No vibration setting
  • Seat doesn’t recline

Price

Should Your Baby Sleep In A Swing?

This 2-minute video tells you everything you need to know about sleeping in a swing.

More Than One Way To Calm Your Baby

Baby swings are a great way to calm a fussy baby and give yourself a break. Every baby is different, so if your baby doesn’t always seem happier in a swing, you may want to try a baby carrier. We have an excellent review of the top baby carriers for you to consider.

Tagged With: ,

The information provided through this website should not be used to diagnose or treat a health problem or disease; it is not intended to offer any legal opinion or advice or a substitute for professional safety advice or professional care. Please consult your health care provider, attorney, or product manual for professional advice. Products and services reviewed are provided by third parties; we are not responsible in any way for them, nor do we guarantee their functionality, utility, safety, or reliability. Our content is for educational purposes only.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments