Keeping You Safe, Your Home Smart & Your Life Fun - since 2014

Best DIY Security System: Canary vs Piper vs iSmartAlarm vs Novi vs Ring

How do we keep this site running? This post may contain affiliate links — the cost is the same to you, but we get a referral fee. Compensation does not affect rankings. Thanks!

1st
iSmart Alarm logo
2nd
3rd
Ring logo

There are two types of home security systems prevalent on today’s market: those with professional monitoring (by a central monitoring station), and those that are self-monitored (by you and your network of contacts). The former typically includes a fairly steep ($30-$75) monthly fee to cover the cost of the monitoring station, while with the latter you typically only pay for the equipment. Don’t want this added expense of monthly monitoring? Worried about false alarms and getting fined by your city? We hear ya! These are a few of the reasons that self-monitored security systems have become so intriguing. They put you in control of your system, and you have access to cutting edge “smart” technology that you can control from your smartphone. With these DIY (do it yourself) security systems you’re in charge of when the authorities are called to your home and how you secure your home.

101 on DIY Home Security Systems

First, some background on the terminology that gets thrown around, and which we occasionally use interchangeably:

  • DIY (Do It Yourself) can apply to any system, pro or self-monitored, that you can install without the assistance of a professional installer. The advantage here is that you typically know your home better than anyone, and can probably do a better job. You’ll see, it’s easy!
  • Wireless – Your home security system devices (also called sensors), are installed via sticky adhesives instead of having to drill and hardwire them in (something that’s a pain should you ever decide to move – with wireless home security, moving your system is easy (and free)).
  • WiFi/broadband – A security system that runs over your home WiFi or broadband network (i.e., it will need to connect to the internet).
  • Cellular – a security system that runs over a cell network, similar to your smartphone. Sometimes security systems use both WiFi and cellular.
  • Landline – a security system that runs over your telephone line. This typically only applies to older, professionally monitored systems.
  • Z-wave technology – a standard that allows smart home devices (think door locks, lights, thermostat, etc.) to be powered by and compatible with your home security system.

All in One Vs Separate Component Systems

When you think of a security system, you probably think of a base unit with separate sensors (door, window, motion, etc.) like iSmartAlarm. While some of these systems are designed this way, others are “all in one,” meaning they are a single unit device with all the sensors built-in to it. For example, Canary, Novi, Piper and Ring (all reviewed in this article) are lone devices that include motion sensor and video footage. There are no door/window sensors that need to be installed. We will discuss more of this in each products’ individual review, but we wanted to give you a “heads up” on what to expect as you learn about each companies’ offerings.

What’s So Great About Self-Monitored?

Here are a few important things you should know about self-monitored home security systems before purchasing one:

  • There are no monthly contracts – that means you will not have to pay a fine if you cancel after a few months or years. This is similar to the “contract” you enter into with your cable television provider, for example.
  • All of the systems mentioned in this article are self-monitored. That means you, or someone in your network of contacts, is in charge of contacting the appropriate authorities if your alarm is triggered.
  • The only additional fee you may have (depending on the company you choose) is for cloud storage video recording. This fee pays for space on the cloud where your video camera footage and the activity noted by your sensors are saved.
  • No drilling into your walls, typically. Everything is plug and play or peel and stick. Some devices may have mounts that require some drilling.

iSmartAlarm Review

iSmartAlarm#1

View on Amazon
Visit Website

iSmartAlarm sent us a system to test out in exchange for an unbiased review. We began testing iSmartAlarm back in January 2015 and were overall pleased with its performance. The installation process was easy except for the iCamera KEEP. Fortunately, customer service helped us through it. Overall, we had a great experience with customer service. We did initially have to contact them more than we wanted to, but they always answered our questions, had short wait times, and helped us learn more about the system. Their equipment isn’t the most attractive, but it performs well.

Since testing the system a couple years ago, the equipment hasn’t changed aesthetically or performance wise. Home security is constantly evolving and the fact that iSmartAlarm hasn’t changed much the past couple of years is a bit disappointing since we think there are a few things they could improve on. That being said, there are numerous DIY home security systems on the market, but only a handful of reliable ones. iSmartAlarm is definitely one of the more reliable ones, which is one of the reasons we’ve chosen it as our best DIY security system.

Pros

Cons

  • Great customer service
  • Android and iOS apps
  • Audio detection for alarms (e.g. CO detector, smoke alarm, etc.)
  • Add emergency contacts
  • Email, phone and help center support
  • Great equipment quality
  • Cameras perform well and have night vision
  • Key fob is pretty handy and works within 30 feet
  • Easy and fast installation
  • Inexpensive home security option
  • Delayed notifications
  • No backup source
  • Inside only
  • Spot camera, when used as a baby monitor, has been known to trigger false alerts

Pricing

  • iCamera Keep – $99.00
  • iCamera Keep Pro – $139.99
  • Spot –$84.99
  • Keypad – Out of stock
  • Motion Detector – $23.60
  • Door/Window Sensor (two-pack) – $59.97
  • Smart Switch – $31.99
  • Preferred – $144.52 (includes 1 CubeOne (the brain of the system with siren built-in), 2 contact sensors, 1 motion sensor, 2 remote tags)
  • Deluxe – $184.99 (includes 1 CubeOne, 4 contact sensors, 1 motion sensor, 2 remote tags)
  • Premium Package (Video Camera Bundle) – Out of stock (includes 1 CubeOne, 1 iCamera Keep, 2 contact sensors, 1 motion sensor, 2 remote tags)

Coupon Code

iSmartAlarm savings vary based on the season so click this link to make sure you get the best deal.

Tech Specs

  • 1-year warranty
  • Night vision
  • 110 dB siren

Read our in-depth iSmartAlarm Review

Canary Review

Canary Flex#2

View on Amazon
Visit Website

Canary is an all-in-one system and has two devices for you to choose from, Canary and Canary Flex. These can be connected on the same account (up to a total of 4 connected devices). In our opinion, the Canary Flex is the better of the two cameras. Canary Flex can be used inside or outside, and has fewer issues according to customer reviews we’ve read online. Canary Flex can be plugged into an outlet or recharged with lithium ion batteries, so you don’t have to worry about installing it next to an outlet. It’s unfortunate that the Flex doesn’t have the air monitoring capabilities that the original Canary had. We would’ve loved to see this feature carried over to the Flex. Also, Flex does not have a siren, so there is no way to “scare off” intruders unless you speak to them via two-way talk. However, we love that Flex is small and discreet, which means you can easily find space for it in your home.

Pros

Cons

  • Canary Cloud offers access to events from the past 24 hours for free, and you can bookmark up to 5 videos
  • Great customer service, according to online reviews we’ve read
  • Ability to add emergency contacts
  • Air quality, temperature and humidity sensor (Canary only)
  • Android and iOS app
  • 60-day money back guarantee
  • Canary Flex can be used indoors and outdoors
  • Can only connect up to 4 devices
  • Some lagging
  • Flex does not monitor air quality and has no siren

Pricing

  • $129.90 for one Canary or $315.99 for two pack
  • $155.56 for one Canary Flex
  • Free shipping
  • Canary Cloud
    • Free Access: 1-day storage of 10-second video previews for free
    • Membership: 30-day storage of full-length videos for $9.99/month or $99/year

Coupon Code

Canary products are generally discounted from MSRP on Amazon.

Tech Specs

  • 1-year warranty (2-years for devices with cloud membership)
  • 1080p HD camera
  • Canary field of view: 147° wide-angle lens
  • Canary Flex field of view: 116° wide-angle lens
  • Night vision
  • 90+ dB siren (Canary only)

Read our in-depth Canary Review

Ring Review

Ring Stick Up Cam#3

View on Amazon
Visit Website

Ring has some pretty cool equipment. Known for its video doorbells, Ring also offers 5 outside security cameras for you to choose from. You can sync your equipment together so you can watch for any suspicious activity around your home. Charging options include battery, solar and wire operated. The unique thing about Ring’s cameras is that the Floodlight and Spotlight cameras have built-in lights, which turn on when motion is detected. This is an extra deterrent that may be enough on it’s own to send a potential burglar running for the hills. The Spotlight cameras are fairly new, but as they evolve and integrate with the Ring system, we can see it helping Ring prove more competitive in the DIY home security space.

Pros

Cons

  • Many options
  • Weatherproof
  • Attractive equipment
  • If your equipment is stolen, Ring will replace it for free
  • Android and iOS app
  • Indoor and outdoor options
  • Reports of excellent customer service according to customers
  • No backup source
  • Cannot add emergency contacts

Pricing

  • Floodlight Cam – $248.83
  • Spotlight Cam Wired – [[Amazon_Link_Text]]
  • Spotlight Cam Battery – [[Amazon_Link_Text]]
  • Spotlight Cam Solar – Coming Soon
  • Stick Up Cam – [[Amazon_Link_Text]]
  • Ring Video Doorbell$149.00
  • Ring Video Doorbell 2$198.99
  • Ring Video Doorbell Pro$249.00
  • Ring Video Doorbell Elite$450.00
  • If you choose no cloud recording plan, you get instant alerts, can stream video and audio, can watch live view and have lifetime theft protection.
    • Basic: $30/year or $3/month, per camera
    • Protect: $100/year or $10/month, unlimited cameras

Coupon Code

There are no Ring security coupons available.

Tech Specs

Ring offers five security cameras, and each comes with a one-year warranty on parts and a lifetime purchase protection replacement in case of theft.

  • 1080p video for all except Stick Up Cam, which has 720p
  • Night vision
  • Floodlights or spotlights for all except Stick Up Cam
  • 110 dB siren
  • Spotlight Cams: 140° field of view
  • Floodlight Cam: 270º field of view
  • Stick Up Cam: 80º field of view

Read our in-depth Ring Doorbells Review

Best DIY Home Security System Comparison Table

Even though iSmartAlarm is more comparable to what is typically thought of as a security system, we feel that lone devices like Canary and Ring can be used as their own independent security systems too. We’ll let you make the decision as to which fits your security needs. Take a look at the comparison table below or click one of the company links below to jump to a specific security system review.

 1st Place: iSmartAlarm2nd Place: Canary Flex3rd Place: Ring Floodlight CamNoviPiper NV
1st Place: iSmartAlarm2nd Place: Canary3rd Place: RingNoviPiper NV
Read ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead Review
View on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonNot AvailableView on Amazon
Visit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit Website
System Price$179.76$129.99$153.00$299.00Check on Amazon
Power SourceAC/DC Wall AdapterAC/DC Wall Adapter or Rechargeable BatteryHardwiredBatteryAC/DC Wall Adapter
Backup SourceNoneRechargeable BatteryNoneNone3AA Batteries
Motion-Activated CameraCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
IndoorCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
OutdoorCheckmarkCheckmark
Warranty1 year1 year (2 years if you purchase Cloud membership)1 year1 year limited1 year limited
Field of View350° x 40° pan and tilt (iCamera KEEP Pro)147° wide-angle lens270°170°180° Diagonal
Night VisionCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Siren110 dB90+ dB110 dB90 dB105 dB
Two-Way TalkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Key FobCheckmark
Extra Motion Detector$23.60
Smoke AlarmCheckmark
Extra Entry Sensor$59.97 (two pack)
Smart Plug$31.99
Video Doorbell$153.00
Z-Wave, Zigbee, Insteon CompatibilityZ-Wave
Read ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead ReviewRead Review
View on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonView on AmazonNot AvailableView on Amazon
Visit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit Website

Novi Review

Novi Security

Visit Website

Novi was bumped out of our top 3 because other companies have evolved and created new products while Novi has been rather stagnant. However, we still think Novi is among the best DIY security systems. The Novi camera attaches to your ceiling and can only be used inside. It is a lone device as well, similar to Canary. What makes it stand out from the competition is that inside each camera is also a smoke detector. So, instead of having multiple things attached to your ceiling, Novi can cut that number in half. The downside is, it takes only photos, not video, but you can take as many photos as you want with Novi.

Pros

Cons

  • Battery lasts 1 year
  • No wires or power cord
  • Android and iOS app
  • Add emergency contacts
  • Adjust motion sensitivity
  • Photoelectric smoke detector in every sensor
  • Made in the U.S.A.
  • Doesn’t take video, takes photos instead
  • Inside only
  • Not much feedback online from customers
  • No backup
  • Firmware problems in the past

Pricing

  • Starter Pack – $299.00
  • Additional Camera – $179.00

Coupon Code

There are no Novi security coupons available.

Tech Specs

  • 1-year limited warranty
  • 720p HD camera
  • Night vision
  • 90 dB siren

Piper NV Review

Piper NV

View on Amazon
Visit Website

Piper NV was previously in our top 3 for best DIY security system, but, similar to Novi, it was bumped out due to other companies releasing more current products. Piper is a lone device that monitors video, temperature, light and humidity. It does not have separate components like iSmartAlarm or what you’d consider a typical security system to have. What makes it great? It’s easy to install, offers two-way audio and has decent customer service. It is one of the few self-monitored systems that supports Z-Wave technology. What does it lack? This camera can only be used inside, and it is not weatherproof. There are also reports of this camera malfunctioning and the software lacking functionality.

Pros

Cons

  • Motion detection activated
  • View video remotely on iOS and Android
  • Two-way audio
  • Temperature, light, humidity sensor
  • Easy installation
  • Piper does a good job responding to Amazon reviews
  • Battery backup
  • Supports Z-Wave
  • Indoor only
  • Reports of some cameras malfunctioning
  • Software could be improved
  • Video is a little shaky

Pricing

Coupon Code

There are no Piper security coupons available.

Tech Specs

  • 1-year limited warranty
  • HD camera
  • Field of view: 180° diagonal
  • Night vision
  • 105 dB siren

Redefining Home Security with DIY Wireless Home Security Systems

More and more people are moving towards DIY solutions because they not only cover home security, but they also include home automation controls. The cost of a security system is much less than the cost of being burglarized. A home invasion is estimated to cost victims about $20,000. That includes items stolen and need replacing as well as criminal justice fees. And don’t forget about the emotional toll it can take your family and you on. Having a burglar enter your home and ransack it doesn’t only create physical damage but it also makes you feel less safe at home. Help your family feel safe today, and find out why these solutions are gaining popularity.

Compare Other Security Cameras

You can add more security to your home by installing home security cameras. Take a look at the best WiFi security cameras and best CCTV systems on the market today. We recommend installing cameras near every entrance of your home, including front doors, back doors, patio doors and garages.

What elements are important to you in a home security system?

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Kimberly researches everything before she buys. She wants to make sure she is getting the best bang for her buck by purchasing the best product/service, which is why she loves her work. She has a degree in Multimedia Journalism and has been researching and writing professionally since 2013 to help consumers make more educated decisions.

Leave a Reply

3 Comments on "Best DIY Security System: Canary vs Piper vs iSmartAlarm vs Novi vs Ring"

avatar
Virgie
Virgie

What about the new Nest security system that just came out?

Guest
Guest

I’ve been looking to switch to DIY self monitoring from monitored security because we moved to a place that’s more secure and I don’t see the need to pay a lot for the extra protection but do like to have peace of mind. Anyone have experience with any of these top companies that can help make my decision easier?

wpDiscuz

Send this to a friend