Protect America Review: Is It The Best Home Security System?

To sustain this free service, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. This doesn’t affect rankings. Our review process.

Protect America equipment (caption: Protect America Review)Protect America is a DIY-installation home security system that requires a 3-year contract for professional monitoring, but their equipment and monthly pricing blows many similar services out of the water. And it’s one of the few security companies to let you choose between landline, broadband and cellular monitoring for any package you want.

While affordability is a major plus, is Protect America able to deliver dependable security at such a surprisingly reasonable cost? Our experts find out.

Visit Protect America’s Website | 877-459-7554

Article Overview

Protect America

4.35 / 5
Protect America
Customer Service & Reputation 4.3
Equipment 4.3
Technology 4.0
Value 4.5
Ease Of Use 4.8


  • Has 6 monitoring stations
  • Easy to set up and use
  • Compatible with Amazon Alexa (not Google Home)
  • Self-installation
  • 15-day money back guarantee


  • 3-year monitoring contract required
  • You must pay 100% of the contract even if you cancel

Protect America equipment

Key Features

  • 6 monitoring stations, so if one goes down (e.g., due to a natural disaster), another is there as a backup
  • You choose landline, broadband or cellular monitoring (we recommend cellular because landline can be cut and broadband won’t work during a power outage)
  • BBB rating: A
  • Pet-friendly motion sensors ignore the motion of most pets less than 40 pounds
  • Protect America’s SMART Connect app controls your home automation, energy management and video cameras in one place
  • Z-wave connectivity (a wireless communication protocol) to home automation equipment
  • Lifetime warranty
  • An available medical alert system
  • Protect America’s monitoring station, COPS, contacts you within 60 seconds
  • Self-installation

Battery Backup

If the power goes out in your home, battery backup will keep your Protect America system on and your home protected. Protect America has an 18 to 24-hour battery backup (24 hours is the standard in home security).

Protect America does not send alerts for power outages; however, the activity log should show a power outage. The backup battery is rechargeable, so once power is restored, the battery will recharge back to 18-24 hours, so it is ready for any future needs.

The entire system will continue to work during a power outage unless the equipment requires a high-speed internet connection (e.g., cameras). Door/window sensors, motion sensors, glass break sensors, etc. do not require a high-speed internet connection, so they will work with battery backup and you will be informed of any triggers to these devices.

App Features

Android App | iOS App

Below are typical functions you can control within a home security app. The included column lists those supported by the Protect America app. Please know that to use some of the features you must have certain equipment. For example, you cannot lock/unlock doors unless you have smart locks in place that are compatible with your security system.

Arm/Disarm SystemCheckmark
Smart Plug ControlCheckmark
Lock/Unlock Smart DoorsCheckmark
View Camera Live StreamCheckmark
Camera Controls (Pan, Tilt, Zoom)
View Recorded VideoCheckmark
View Doorbell CameraCheckmark
Image Sensor Images
Event HistoryCheckmark
Smart Thermostat ControlsCheckmark
Control LightsCheckmark
Create Programs/SchedulesCheckmark
Garage Door ControlCheckmark
Multi-Factor AuthenticationCheckmark

See our dedicated coverage of the Protect America SMART Connect app, that you can use to remotely control your security system.


There are no installation fees, and you get up to $1,400 of wireless equipment free. Below are the monitoring packages and included equipment with each package. Unfortunately, Protect America doesn’t list its equipment prices, so we are unable to share that information with you at this time.

Note: If you want a camera, you must upgrade to broadband or cellular monitoring.

Landline Monitoring Price/Month$19.99$37.99$42.99
Broadband Monitoring Price/Month$41.99$49.99$54.99
Cellular Monitoring Price/Month$41.99$49.99$54.99
Control PanelCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Door/Window Sensors ($39.99)3914
Motion Detectors ($99.00)111
Yard Signs ($12.00)111
Door/Window Sticker ($2.25)444
Keychain Remote ($49.00)
Glass Break Sensor ($99.00)
Garage Door Sensor
Recessed Door/Window Sensor
Ion Plunger Recessed Door/Window Sensor
Smoke Detector
CO Detector
Firefighter Sensor
Water/Freeze Sensor
Medical Alert Pendant
Indoor Camera ($99.00)
Outdoor Camera
Doorbell Camera ($179.00)


Use this link to get the best deal we can offer from Protect America.

Home Automation Equipment

You have to upgrade to broadband or cellular monitoring for home automation capabilities. Below are some popular home automation options for Protect America.

What Do People Think Of Protect America?

Positive Reviews

Mr ** was amazing, patient and had great knowledge about everything his company has to offer to protect a home. He took the time to carefully explain what would work best in our house. I would applaud his work ethic and excellence in customer service. I will be referring our friends and family to this company and Mr ** in the future. – Tara, ConsumerAffairs 4/5/2019

Hands down the most polite, sincere, and effective customer support team I’ve ever had the pleasure of working with in my entire life. As for the hardware, the equipment isn’t straight out of the Jetson’s, but it’s rock solid nonetheless. There seems to be a lot of people with issues having to do with the 36 month long contract terms. This shouldn’t be a huge deal if you do a tiny bit of thinking and use a little logic before signing up. Maybe ask yourself a couple questions like, “do I plan on moving overseas in the next 36 months?”, or maybe something like “do I have adequate finances to uphold my end of the contract for the full term of the contract?”. Seriously people, it is a CONTRACT…do you just go into a car dealership with your mouth running a mile a minute and proclaiming that every person you come across is as dumb as a doornail all because you want the current year model that was just released but still have over half your lease to go? Probably not, or atleast I sure hope not…why? Because when you lease a car you sign a contract for a specified period of time and you’re expected to follow the terms of the contract or face potential penalties for infractions. Same concept applies to home security…a contract is a binding agreement… didn’t we all learn that on the playground as first graders with the whole ‘pinky swear’ or something insanely simple minded like that? – Bruce B., Yelp 4/4/2019

Negative Reviews

Received faulty equipment from day one and it took several phones calls to get it rectified. My sensors kept falling off the windows and even though I told them not to send police they did anyway which cost me $25 a pop plus an extra fee when I have to renew my license with the city. Now my biggest fear is when my 3-year contract is up I’m told by several former customers that they still charge your credit card even though you have canceled service with them. I CAN’T WAIT TO GET RID OF THEM!!! PROTECT AMERICA IS ONLY LOOKING OUT FOR THEMSELVES AND SCREWING THE LITTLE PEOPLE! – Donna, ConsumerAffairs 4/5/2019

Stay away! Don’t bother! What is it about alarm companies that they seem to want to trap people in? Protect America is no exception. Their system functions correctly, but the company is terrible. Their is almost nothing you can do self-service on the web site; basically any change requires dealing with some person and answering the same questions over and over. In our case, we are moving to another state and will be in temporary housing for several months while we look for a house. There’s simply no way I’m paying a monthly charge while the system sits in a box. I offered to pay a reasonable cancellation fee for the 18 months remaining on our extension and they declined. So I just blocked their auto payment with my bank. We can argue about this later and get to a reasonable conclusion. Really painful to deal with this company. – Jon P., Yelp 2/12/2019

Protect America vs Other Companies

See what the key differences are between Protect America and other leading home security companies.

Protect America vs Frontpoint

  • Protect America requires a 3-year contract, Frontpoint has no long term contracts.
  • Protect America offers broadband and landline monitoring packages, all of Frontpoint’s are cellular monitoring.
  • Frontpoint has a better customer service reputation.

Compare Protect America and Frontpoint

Protect America vs SimpliSafe

  • SimpliSafe has no long term contracts, so you can cancel whenever you want. Protect America requires a 3-year contract.
  • Protect America’s equipment lineup is more thorough than SimpliSafe’s including an outdoor camera.
  • Protect America’s app is much more thorough and has more features than SimpliSafe’s app.

Compare Protect America and SimpliSafe

Is Protect America The Best?

Visit Protect America’s Website | 877-459-7554

Our research indicates that Protect America is a dependable home security company, and there are no glaring red flags that we see. If you decide to go with them, we do recommend that you upgrade to cellular monitoring. However, if you live in a remote place and don’t have reliable cell coverage or high-speed internet, you have the option of landline monitoring (vs. no monitoring at all).

If you want to see how Protect America compares against other home security companies we’ve reviewed, read our top home security systems showdown. We’ve reviewed over a dozen companies and include pros and cons for each.

Would you trust Protect America to secure your home?

About The Author:

Kimberly is our home security expert, and has been researching and writing about security and safety since 2013, covering everything from security systems and home automation to identity theft protection, home warranties, medical alert systems and more. She has personally tested hundreds of system components and interfaced with dozens of home security companies to find out what's happening behind the scenes.

In 2018, she had her first child, and that opened up a whole new avenue of security experience with baby gear. She wanted to purchase the safest items for her family.

Kimberly received her Bachelor of Arts in multimedia journalism from Simpson College. Her natural curiosity helps her research as she seeks the truth when learning about, comparing and personally testing products and services.

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.

Disclaimer: This website contains reviews, opinions and information regarding products and services manufactured or provided by third parties. We are not responsible in any way for such products and services, and nothing contained here should be construed as a guarantee of the functionality, utility, safety or reliability of any product or services reviewed or discussed. Please follow the directions provided by the manufacturer or service provider when using any product or service reviewed or discussed on this website.

Notify of
Oldest Most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Josh G
September 25, 2019 2:48 pm

I’m almost ready to pull the trigger on Protect America given how attractive their pricing is (besides I’m convinced the home security industry is not actually security companies, just a bunch of marketing companies that spend a lot of $ on advertising). I do have a question on their battery backup first though – you say 18-24 hours. Does this mean that in the event of a prolonged power outage, the system would stay online for a maximum of 24 hours? What happens after that? Does none of it work anymore or does the signal to the monitoring station simply get interrupted? In other words, is the battery backup for the cellular part or for the entire system plus sensors? Thanks in advance for your time!

Sarah W
August 22, 2019 2:31 pm

So I’m really tempted to go with Protect America given their pricing and generally positive reviews. But the cancellation nightmare stories are making me hesitate. So just to clarify, if I sign up, I have to sign up for 3 years, and if I cancel, I have to pay the full remaining contract amount? That seems kind of crazy given that the trial period is only 2 weeks! Does the trial period start when the equipment is shipped, or when I receive it? And how does the Protect American cancelation policy compare to industry norms?

Stewie G
August 17, 2019 2:30 pm

Great review – I’m so tempted to go with Protect America’s $19.99/month landline plan because it’s just so much more affordable. Can I get just about any piece of equipment/device with this, the only difference is that the monitoring is transmitted via landline instead of cellular? If that’s the case it seems like a steal.

And on the subject of landline monitoring – you mention it’s not as secure. Isn’t that mostly the case in older homes where the wires are exposed/above ground? In newer builds phone lines tend to be buried underground and IMO would be difficult to get to without creating a noticeable commotion in the yard.