Best Encrypted Messaging App: Signal vs Telegram vs WhatsApp vs iMessage vs Viber vs Wire vs Wickr & More

To sustain this free service, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. This doesn’t affect rankings. Our review process.

1st
Signal logo
2nd
Wire logo
3rd
Wickr logo
Compare All Apps

We’ve all seen it happen to politicians and celebrities: texting and social media posts can wreak havoc on your life if your “private” messages, photos or other shared content falls into the wrong hands. If you want to message without it coming back to haunt you — or you need to share totally confidential info — it’s a no-brainer to use an encrypted messaging app.

Article Overview

Why Should I Use Encrypted Messaging?

Your smartphone’s text (SMS) messages aren’t encrypted, but why does that matter? Any content you include in your SMS message is easily viewable by your mobile carrier and government officials — and highly susceptible to hackers. Even if you’re using two-factor authentication, skilled techies can steal your codes.

What’s more, SMS messages leak metadata. Although metadata doesn’t include information about the message’s contents, it does include the phone number of the sender and recipient. So, if you don’t want anyone keeping tabs on who you’re chatting with, regular texting is not on your side.

Some privacy hawks even worry about a recent ruling by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) that gives cell carriers more authority to block SMS messages. The ruling’s goal is to reduce SMS spam, but some believe this opens up a can of worms for potential freedom of speech violations.

Essential Features For The Highest Security

If you’re messaging financial information or other highly sensitive confidential content, you’ll want to make sure the encrypted messaging app you choose has two key features.

End-To-End Encryption

End-to-end encryption is an absolute necessity if you want your messages to stay private. This type of encryption scrambles messages on the sender’s device and doesn’t unscramble them until they get to the recipient’s device.

End-to-end encryption makes it nearly impossible for anyone to see the content of any message — as long as the encryption protocol is foolproof. But as you’ll see in our reviews, most private messaging apps use their own protocol, so they can differ in how secure they are. Still, end-to-end encrypted apps are much more secure than popular apps, like Instagram, Snapchat, Skype and Slack, that don’t have it.

Open Source Platform

Why does open source matter? Any app can claim to have the best security, but if their encryption coding isn’t open to the public, how sure can you be that it’s consistently safe to use?

An open source platform, however, can be rigorously inspected by independent security experts for faulty coding, bugs and breaches — the same goes for all the app updates that the company releases. Open source apps (that experts verify) give you an added level of confidence that your content is indeed being encrypted continually.

Tip: To ensure the highest level of security and privacy, always update your apps as soon as possible when the company releases an update. 

Best Encrypted Messaging App

We’ve chosen our top 3 winners based primarily on their reliable encryption capabilities and app performance to give you the most secure and usable options available. We’ve also included each app’s primitive cryptography for our hardcore tech readers. If you’re not as concerned about total privacy, be sure to read all of our reviews to find your best option.

Signal Review

#1

Visit Website | Download iOS App | Download Google Play App

Security experts widely consider Signal by Open Whisperer Systems the gold standard for private messaging. This free messaging app uses automatic end-to-end encryption, is open source and has undergone numerous (and successful) independent audits of its cryptography over the years.

Signal also allows you to verify the identity of your contacts. Each conversation has a unique safety number (often referred to as a fingerprint or key) that allows you to confirm the security of your messages and calls with specific contacts.

This app gives you all of the basic messaging tools you’ll need, including group chats, voice and video calls, read receipts and emoji support. Signal is your best option if you’re looking for super secure messaging, voice, video, group messaging and file sharing. It has native applications for iOS, Android, Mac and Windows PC.

Primitive cryptography: Signal uses the OTR protocol, 256-bit symmetric AES encryption, Curve25519 and HMAC-SHA256.

Pros

Cons

  • Open source – thoroughly inspected and verified by many outside experts
  • Meta information is secure
  • Can verify senders’ fingerprints
  • Ability to set messages to self destruct (like Snapchat)
  • Can add a separate lock screen on the app for added security
  • Operates on grant and donation funding from Freedom of the Press Foundation, the Knight Foundation and many more nonprofits
  • Interface isn’t as polished as others

Price

  • Free

Wire Review

#2

Visit Website | Download iOS App | Download Google Play App

Wire is a Swiss-made encryption messaging app that uses its own Proteus end-to-end encryption protocol that was inspired by Signal. Wire has a robust feature set that’s fully functional on all of its platforms, including texting, audio calling, video calling, file transfers up to 25 MB, group messaging and group calling.

You can also have up to 3 separate accounts to use for different messaging purposes, e.g., personal, work and dating. Wire offers native applications for iOS, Android, Windows, Mac and Linux. 

Primitive cryptography: Wire uses the Proteus protocol (based on Signal), Curve25519, ChaCha20 and HMAC-SHA256.

Pros

Cons

    • Invites ongoing independent audits of its cryptography (open source)
    • Doesn’t require a phone number to use, rather usernames
    • Can verify senders’ fingerprints
    • Ability to set content to self destruct in a defined time period
    • Can share documents up to 25MB/file
    • Group messaging with up to 230 people and group calling up to 10 users
    • Enterprise option
  • Android app can be buggy with non-security-related features, like a small chat window and lagging messaging (but Wire is extremely responsive about fixing bugs asap)
  • Some users say that video calls are weak

Price

Wire features a free app for personal use and a Pro app upgrade for businesses that starts at €6 (approx. $6.78) per user per month. You can get a free 30-day trial for the Pro version with no credit card required.

Wickr Review

#3

Visit Website | Download iOS App | Download Google Play App

U.S.-based Wickr offers the free Wickr Me app for personal use and paid Wickr Pro and Enterprise platforms for businesses looking for company-wide secure messaging. This company is all about protecting privacy and transparency in its open-source software.

Many independent experts have thoroughly inspected and verified Wickr’s encryption strength. The company even offers a ‘bug bounty’ — up to a $100,000 reward to anyone finding potential security vulnerabilities that seriously compromise their encryption.

Wickr Me and its business platforms give you secure texting, voice calls, group messaging and file sharing (but you must pay for the Pro plan to share files over 10MB). It offers native apps for iOS, Android, Mac and Windows PC.

Primitive cryptography: Wickr the Wickr Secure Messaging Protocol, ECDH512, AES-256 and HMAC-SHA256.

Pros

Cons

  • Open source with numerous independent audits of encryption code
  • Can verify senders’ fingerprints
  • Ability to set content to self destruct
  • Provides transparency reports on website
  • Secure business platform like Slack but with end-to-end encryption, even for voice calls
  • Free file size sharing is limited to 10MB/file (must upgrade to paid plan for higher limits)
  • Several complaints that the Android app’s functionality is buggy (iOS app is much better)

Price

Wickr Me is a free app for personal use. Wickr also offers Pro and Enterprise solutions that start at $4.99 per user per month.

Each App’s Encryption At A Glance

When glancing at this table, the more green checks, the better for your encrypted privacy.

 1st: Signal2nd: Wire3rd: WickrWhatsAppViberiMessageTelegram
End-To-End EncryptionCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Encryption Turned On By DefaultCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Open SourceCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Verify Contact FingerprintsCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Set Message To Self DestructCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkLimitedCheckmark
Encrypts All MetadataCheckmarkCheckmark
No IP Address or Timestamp Logs Kept By CompanyCheckmarkCheckmark

Other Encrypted Messaging Apps

We’ve also reviewed other popular encrypted messaging apps, some which you’ve probably heard of — did you know that iPhone’s iMessage (the default iPhone messaging app) is encrypted by default? In stark contrast, Android’s default messaging and chat app, Android Messages, is not end-to-end encrypted (take note Android users!).  Some of the following apps we review are more secure than others, so pay close attention to the pros/cons we provide.

iMessage | Telegram  | Viber | WhatsApp

iMessage Review

iMessage logo

Many Apple users don’t even realize they’re already using encrypted messaging via iMessage, Apple’s default messaging app, but is iMessage enough to protect your privacy? The short answer is no.

iMessage does use end-to-end encryption, but it’s not open source, so no one outside of Apple can review its cryptography. It also doesn’t have contact ID verification. Many experts have cautioned about its security, so we recommend using a different private messaging app.

Primitive cryptography: iMessage uses RSA-1280 (encryption), ECDSA 256 (signing), AES 128 and SHA-1.

Pros

Cons

  • End-to-end encryption always turned on
  • Automatically built-in with iOS and Mac
  • Syncs well with other apps
  • Lots of GIF stickers to liven up messaging
  • Experts say it’s not secure enough
  • Not open source
  • Doesn’t have contact ID verification
  • Can’t set messages to self destruct
  • Doesn’t encrypt metadata

Telegram Review

Telegram logo

Visit Website | Download iOS App | Download Google Play App

Telegram is a popular private messaging app with end-to-end encryption, a slick interface, speed and lots of features. One big plus for some users is that Telegram doesn’t limit the file size of media or documents you share. And you can set messages and files to self destruct after you send them.

However, if ultimate security is a necessity, Telegram falls short. While it has open source API for developers, its server-side code is closed source and proprietary. And many experts agree that Telegram isn’t very secure.

If you’re simply looking for an alternate messaging app that you can use and sync on multiple devices, Telegram’s a great option (as long as you don’t need uber encryption). Telegram offers native applications for iOS, Android, Windows Phone, Mac, Linux and Windows PC.

Primitive cryptography: Telegram uses the MTProto protocol, AES-256, RSA 2048 encryption and SHA-256.

Pros

Cons

  • Polished interface
  • Very fast
  • No size limits on files or media you share
  • Can set messages to self destruct
  • Group chatting with 200+ people
  • Photo and video editing tools and fun GIF stickers
  • Not as secure as many other encrypted messaging apps
  • Not entirely open source
  • Encryption isn’t set by default (you have to make sure you turn on Secret mode)
  • Doesn’t thoroughly encrypt all metadata

Price

  • Free

Viber Review

Viber logo

Visit Website | Download iOS App | Download Google Play App

VyprVPN‘s parent company, Rakuten, offers a fun private messaging app that’s most similar to Telegram, with the big exception that Viber’s end-to-end encryption is always turned on by default.

This app offers a lot of functionality, including regular messaging, file sharing, audio and video calls, instant voice and video, group messaging with unlimited users, hidden chat rooms and more.

Viber’s encryption is based on Signal’s protocol, but they’ve tweaked it with their own proprietary additions (meaning it can’t be independently audited). Another downside — experts say that Viber’s security underperforms when compared to Signal and other ultra-secure messaging apps. Viber has native apps for iOS, Android, Mac, Linux and Windows PC.

Primitive cryptography: Viber uses its own protocol, Curve25519, AES 256, Salsa20 128 and HMAC-SHA256.

Pros

Cons

  • Sleek interface
  • Can verify senders’ fingerprints
  • Hidden and self-destructing chats (but self destruct isn’t available for everything you send)
  • Group messaging with unlimited users
  • Thousands of GIF stickers to liven up your messaging
  • Encryption coding isn’t open source
  • Doesn’t thoroughly encrypt all metadata

Price

  • Free

WhatsApp Review

WhatsApp logo

Visit Website | Download iOS App | Download Google Play App

WhatsApp, perhaps the best-known app in our reviews, has now partnered with Signal’s Open Whisperer Systems to add the same top-class encryption methods they use for all their apps (iOS, Android, Windows Phone). So, what are the differences between WhatsApp and Signal?

WhatsApp is the most popular texting alternative, so your existing contacts are more likely already using it. But the downside is that Facebook owns WhatsApp, so you’re putting yourself in the hands of Facebook’s logging practices.

While WhatsApp end-to-end encryption hides your messaging content, Facebook can still collect some of your meta information, like the location of your phone. WhatsApp is available for iOS, Android, Windows Phone, Nokia, Mac and Windows PC.

Primitive cryptography: WhatsApp uses the OTR protocol, Curve25519, AES-256 and HMAC-SHA256.

Pros

Cons

  • Open source (uses Signal’s protocol)
  • More commonly used than other private messaging apps
  • Can verify senders’ fingerprints
  • Can share documents up to 100MB/file
  • Easy group chatting with 250+ people
  • Reports that meta information isn’t entirely secure
  • Owned by Facebook, which is plagued by ongoing privacy concerns (although Facebook claims that it doesn’t monitor WhatsApp)

Price

  • Free

How Does End-To-End Encryption Work?

Check out this brief Wall Street Journal video that does a great job of explaining in detail how end-to-end encryption works to shield your messages from prying eyes.

Other Ways To Protect Your Privacy

Using two-factor authentication whenever you’re online adds an important layer of security for your activity. Another excellent tool is a VPN (Virtual Private Network). VPNs hide all of your online activity from prying eyes. Be sure to read our reviews of the best VPNs to learn all about these affordable and easy-to-use services.

Even if you use multiple layers of security, your confidential information is still vulnerable to hackers. That’s where an identity theft protection service can bring you even more peace of mind. Check out our reviews of the best identity theft protection services to see how they can protect you.

How do you protect your online privacy?

Disclaimer: This website contains reviews, opinions and information regarding products and services manufactured or provided by third parties. We are not responsible in any way for such products and services, and nothing contained here should be construed as a guarantee of the functionality, utility, safety or reliability of any product or services reviewed or discussed. Please follow the directions provided by the manufacturer or service provider when using any product or service reviewed or discussed on this website.

While attending the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill’s graduate school for journalism and public relations, Sally began a long career researching and writing about hard-to-understand topics, such as insurance and finance. Her additional experience in marketing, fundraising, public relations and financial planning at various foundations and nonprofit organizations over the years has given her the practical tools to inform consumers about making the smartest business and personal financial decisions. Speaking of smart living — growing up in the (at-the-time) per-capita murder capital of the U.S. (Richmond, VA) taught her a thing or two about the need for personal and home safety. Sally stays on top of all the latest gadgets and services to protect her and her teenage daughters from potential predators and thieves. And she brings this knowledge to every article she writes.

Leave a Reply

avatar