Other Home Security Systems Reviews 2019: Abode vs LifeShield vs Protection One vs Scout Alarm

To sustain this free service, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. This doesn’t affect rankings. Our review process.

1st
Frontpoint logo small
2nd
ProtectAmerica logo small
3rd
SimpliSafe logo small
Compare All Companies

Let’s review the home security companies that didn’t make the cut in our main home security comparison (and for your convenience, our top 3 is included to the right). Below are our reviews of the remaining home security companies requested by our readers:

Abode | LifeShield | Protection One | Scout Alarm | Comparison Table

Best Home Security Systems

Before we jump into our company reviews, we suggest you familiarize yourself with our review criteria:

  • Customer Service
  • Equipment
  • Technology
  • Ease Of Use
  • Value

To learn more about some of the features we include in our reviews and why they’re important, jump to our terminology section.

Abode Review

View on Amazon | Visit Website

Abode has a fair number of equipment options, but its app is pretty basic. It only offers a 1-year equipment warranty and 6-7 hours of battery backup. It’s also missing 2-way voice and has only 1 monitoring station. However, if you’re looking for a self-monitoring option with basic equipment, Abode is a solid choice.

Pros

Cons

  • 30-day returns
  • Compatible with Amazon Alexa and Google Home
  • Self-installation
  • No contracts
  • Only 1 monitoring station
  • Little customer feedback online
  • Limited customer support
  • Complaints of camera footage being low resolution
  • No outdoor security cameras
  • 6-7 hours battery backup
  • No 2-way voice

Price

Abode offers more equipment on its website. However, we suggest checking Amazon prices before purchasing on the website because they are often lower than the MSRP (manufacturer’s suggested retail price).

Monitoring Plans

  • Basic: Free self-monitoring and 3-days of media storage
  • Connect: $10/month for cellular backup and 14-days of media storage
  • Secure: $20/month for professional monitoring and cellular backup

Coupon

Use this link to get the best deal we can offer from Abode.

Read Our Full Review Of Abode

LifeShield Review

Visit Website

LifeShield offers a month-to-month monitoring service option, but that may result in higher equipment fees and an activation fee. It only has a 1-year equipment warranty (inferior to the standard lifetime warranty offered by most competitors), but it offers a low monthly monitoring prices (less than $25 per month). If you want a less expensive monthly fee and are okay with the trade-offs, LifeShield may be worth considering.

Pros

Cons

  • Has 3 monitoring stations
  • 30-day money back guarantee
  • Compatible with Amazon Alexa and Google Home
  • Self-installation
  • Month-to-month service available
  • Cellular monitoring available only as a backup
  • Terrible customer service reputation (many complaints about slow response times, uninformed representatives, etc.)
  • Cancellation fees*

*For a 3-year contract, you must pay $15/month left of the contract (2 months = $30, 3 months = $45, etc.). For a 5-year contract, you must pay $9/month remaining in the contract.

Price

 Build Your OwnSHIELD SystemSECURE SystemDoorbell Camera System
Price$109.19$199.15$295.12$346.34
BaseCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Entry Keypad
$35.99 each
CheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Door/Window Sensors
$8.99 each
462
Motion Sensors
$17.99 each
121
Fire Safety Sensors
$20.99 each
11
Keychain Remotes
$14.99 each
11
Indoor Smart Camera
$59.99 each
1
Video Doorbell
$199.99 each
1
Outdoor Smart Camera
$89.99 each
Temperature/Flood Sensor
$29.99 each
Glass Break Sensor
$20.99 each
Security Touchpad
$90.00 each

Monitoring

  • Without cameras: $19.99/month
  • With cameras: $24.98/month (includes 30-day video storage)

Coupon

Use this link to get the best deal we can offer from LifeShield.

Read Our Full Review Of LifeShield

Protection One Review

Visit Website

Protection One (aka Protection 1) has outdated looking equipment compared to other home security companies, which may lead you to question its functionality as well. The equipment warranty length is only 90 days, and you have to upgrade plans to get basic features that others offer in their base packages. Protection One isn’t quite up to par with what we expect from a home security company.

Pros

Cons

  • Has 5 monitoring stations
  • Compatible with Amazon Alexa (not Google Home)
  • 3-year monitoring contract required
  • Live chat doesn’t let you talk back and forth with a person; instead it sends an email
  • Has one of the worst warranty lengths we’ve seen (only 90 days)
  • Wireless doorbell doesn’t have a camera
  • 2-way voice isn’t available with the basic plan
  • Equipment is not modern looking
  • Requires professional installation
  • Cancelling early may result in paying the remaining contract term
  • No money back guarantee

Price

The package prices below are with a 3-year contract. Protection One does not state exactly what equipment is included with each of its plans. So, if you are considering them, be sure to ask a lot of clarifying questions before you sign up.

 SecureSecure +Smart ControlVideo
Price Per Month$34.99$44.99$49.99$54.99
24/7 MonitoringCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Intrusion ProtectionCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Environmental & Life SafetyCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Monitored Fire & CO ProtectionCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Cellular CommunicationCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
2-Way VoiceCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Camera Integrated Motion DetectorCheckmarkCheckmark
Web & Mobile ControlCheckmarkCheckmark
Energy & Home AutomationCheckmarkCheckmark
Video SurveillanceCheckmark
Control PanelCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Door/Window Sensors3333
Motion Sensors1111
Keychain Remotes1111
Image Motion SensorCheckmarkCheckmark
Indoor CameraCheckmark

Additional equipment options include:

  • Keychain Remote
  • Door/Window Sensor
  • Motion Sensor
  • Indoor Camera
  • Outdoor Camera
  • CO Detector
  • Smoke Detector
  • Water Sensor
  • Freeze Sensor
  • Glass Break Sensor
  • Thermostat
  • Smart Switch
  • Smart Door Lock
  • Garage Door Controller
  • Medical Alert Device
  • Wireless Doorbell
  • Fire Fighter
  • Image Motion Sensor

Coupon

Use this link to get the best deal we can offer from Protection One.

Read Our Full Review Of Protection One

Scout Alarm Review

View on Amazon | Visit Website

Most of Scout Alarm’s equipment has a contemporary design and you can even choose the color. But, the sensors are rather bulky. It doesn’t offer an extensive list of equipment options, and the technology isn’t as advanced as its competitors.

Pros

Cons

  • Has 6 monitoring stations
  • 60-day returns
  • Compatible with Amazon Alexa and Google Home
  • Self-installation
  • No contracts
  • Equipment sensors are large
  • Self-monitoring functionality is tied to a monthly payment plan
  • No outdoor security cameras
  • 12-hour battery backup
  • The hub doesn’t have 2-way voice

Price

  • Scout Hub (1 required) – $120
  • Door Panel (each comes with 1 RFID sticker and 2 key fobs) – $50
  • Access Sensor – $20
  • Motion Sensor – $30
  • Indoor Camera – $99
  • Smoke & CO Detector – $50
  • Glass Break Sensor – $50
  • Water Sensor – $30
  • Door Lock – $229
  • Key Fob – $4.99
  • Video Doorbell – $99

Monitoring

  • Always On – $9.99/month self-monitoring
  • Always On+ – $19.99/month professional monitoring

Coupon

Use this link to get the best deal we can offer from Scout Alarm.

Read Our Full Review Of Scout Alarm

Comparison Table

If there are any terms that you don’t understand, we have a terminology section below the table.

 1st: Frontpoint2nd: Protect America3rd: SimpliSafeMost Customizable: Link InteractiveProfessional Installation: ADTBest Home Automation: VivintAbodeLifeShieldProtection OneScout Alarm
Equipment Starting Cost$255.96$0$229Customizable$0$599.99$199$109.19N/A$229
Pro Monitoring Monthly Starting Cost$44.99$21.19$14.99$30.99$27.99$10$20$19.99$34.99$19.99
Contract LengthNone3 YearsNone1-3 Years3 Years3.5-5 YearsNoneNone or 3 Years3 YearsNone
InstallationDIYDIYDIYDIYProfessionalProfessionalDIYDIY or ProfessionalProfessionalDIY
Installation Fee$0$0$0$0$99-$199$49-$199$0$0 or Varies$99$0
Money-Back Guarantee30 Days15 Days60 Days30 Days6 MonthsNone30 Days30 DaysN/A60 Days
Warranty3 YearsLifetime3 Years3 YearsLifetime (Must Pay Additional $)120 Days1 Year1 Year90 Days3 Years
Battery Backup24 Hours18-24 Hours24 Hours8 or 24 Hours24 Hours4 Hours6-7 Hours24 Hours24 Hours12 Hours
Self Monitoring OptionCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Third Party MonitoringCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Main Form Of MonitoringCellularLandline, Broadband & CellularCellularCellularLandline & CellularCellularBroadbandBroadbandLandline & CellularBroadband
Backup Form Of MonitoringBroadbandNoneBroadbandBroadbandCellularBroadbandCellularLandline & CellularCellularCellular
Amazon Alexa CompatibilityCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Google Home CompatibilityCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark

Terminology

  • Equipment Starting Cost – The cost of your system’s equipment can vary based on the devices you select, but these are the base prices for each company. They can go up from there.
  • Pro Monitoring Monthly Starting Cost – This is the lowest monthly fee you should expect to be charged for professional monitoring. The monthly fee can increase depending on the type of monitoring (landline, broadband or cellular) you want and the devices in your system (i.e., cameras and home automation equipment typically result in higher monthly fees).
  • Contract Length – This is the standard length of the contract you’ll be required to sign to maintain monitoring for your system.
  • Installation – Many companies offer do it yourself (DIY) type installation, which is fairly simple since most sensors attach with a peel and stick (similar to a sticker). Some companies still offer professional installation, if you’d prefer that. If you’re worried about purchasing a DIY security system, we answer some of the most commonly asked questions in our DIY frequently asked questions article. We can help you put your cameras, control panel, sensors and other equipment in the perfect spots in our home security installation guide.
  • Installation Fee – DIY installation typically means there is no installation fee. But, if you opt for a company with professional installation, you’ll commonly be charged for it.
  • Money-Back Guarantee – The time you have to return the system for a full refund without being locked into a contract. Be sure to read how each company defines its money-back guarantee before signing a contract.
  • Warranty – This is the amount of time your equipment will be covered for any defects. Each company has exclusions in its warranty — make sure to read carefully so you understand what is and isn’t covered.
  • Battery Backup – This is the amount of time the control panel will operate on battery power during a power outage. Power outages are popular times for burglars to break into homes, so the longer the battery backup time, the better.
  • Self Monitoring Option – If you’d prefer to monitor your system yourself and avoid a professional monitoring fee, you can select one of these companies. Keep in mind, a self-monitored system means if an alarm goes off, you are responsible for contacting the appropriate authorities. So, if you are someone who is often away from or mutes your phone (including air travel), this may not be a great fit for you.
  • Third Party Monitoring – We recommend companies that use a third party for their monitoring needs because it’s extremely difficult for a company to specialize and excel in both security equipment and 24/7 monitoring.
  • Cellular Monitoring – Cellular monitoring is more secure than landline and broadband (internet) because there is no risk of any wires being cut.

Learn more about monitoring stations and the types of monitoring, so you know what to consider before making a purchase.

Who Should You Choose?

If these providers leave you wishing for more options, be sure to read the reviews of our top 3 picks and other well-known home security companies. We’ve reviewed over 14 companies and counting.

Did you find a company that you like?

About The Author:

Kimberly received her Bachelor of Arts in multimedia journalism from Simpson College. Her natural curiosity helps her research as she seeks the truth when learning about, comparing and personally testing products and services.

Kimberly has been writing about security and safety since 2013, covering subjects such as home security and automation, identity theft protection, home warranties, medical alert systems and more. In 2018, she had her first child, and that opened up a whole new avenue of security experience with baby gear. She wanted to purchase the safest items for her family.

Security is a passion of hers, and she knows it isn’t a one size fits all category. With every piece she writes, her goal is to help our readers find the best fit for their unique needs.

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Disclaimer: This website contains reviews, opinions and information regarding products and services manufactured or provided by third parties. We are not responsible in any way for such products and services, and nothing contained here should be construed as a guarantee of the functionality, utility, safety or reliability of any product or services reviewed or discussed. Please follow the directions provided by the manufacturer or service provider when using any product or service reviewed or discussed on this website.

Leave a Reply

avatar